PC Deputy Editor

[bnicho]

If there is a single thing on this forum I personally would like to discourage is "That's not a Classic" type comments. I believe nobody has the right to say that X marque is not a classic or will never be a classic. We all have different tastes and that variety is what makes the classic car world interesting!

Nobody can please everyone all of the time and that applies to PC's choice of feature cars too. I don't consider all the cars PC features are classics. But I also accept that others have opinions different to my own.

Perhaps certain people who have responded to this thread need to take a long hard look at themselves and open their minds a bit. Or consider whether this forum is really the right place for them?

Cheers,

[mr rusty]

Far from the truth- the Minor was a revolutionary car when it came out. In many ways, a huge step up from pre war cars- first mass produced UK monocoque, first mass market UK with rack and pinion, reolutionary US inspired styling, brilliantly designed suspension set up, easy to work on and designed to be reliable.

...relax,nobody is dismissing them- everybody likes a Minor, but you are looking at them as a 'classic' in the wrong way. it's an accepted bona fide classic alright, but not for the reasons you state.....looked at coldly, it's a prety blatant rip-off of the pre-war Traction Avante: monocogue shell, torsion bar springing, rack'n'pinion steering......nothing radical about the Minor at all, it was all someone elses tried and tested technology from 15 years prerviously- it wasn't new, it wasn't radical engineering, and if it hadn't been for the war, the Vauxhall ten would've beaten it to the market for monocogue mass production.

What makes a Minor a Classic is none of that stuff, no, it's more than that, it's nostalgia that does it..the same that makes say a VW beetle or a Standard vanguard or indeed a Marina or Metro a classic, nobody in their right mind would consider the Beetle to be a 'good' car in it's road manners, but it's so much more than the sum of it's parts in other ways- and that's the same thing as for any other old car,that's why the mag put what you consider to be mundane old cars in!

[Grease Monkey]

Morrisand944sman, you are getting my back up, it's people like you who put off the younger generation from getting into classic cars, a typical narrow minded bigot. I'm 58 years old and I hope never turn into you, if the classic car scene is to move forward we have encourage the youngsters into our hobby, I collect cars that I remember from my youth, be they good or bad, that doesn't matter, they are all part of our heritage and deserve to be saved, you may not like it, but you are very blinkered in your views.

Yours Angrily
John Simpson.

[Luxobarge]

See what happens when this subject comes up?

Enough already - lock on.